banegame's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[And The Sun Still Shines]

Really well done. Are you part of the BCA FX course?

tommykong95 responds:

Thanks for commenting. No, I just learn through his animations

[Shadow Hunter - Extended]

Outstanding. so much has already been said about this piece, so I won't be redundant. Simply put, you certainly know what you're doing (as a team or solo, however this was made)

deweydarklight responds:

Thanks a lot! I appreciate it very much.

[Fiery Christmas]

Hey there Adam, NG... yeah... I like BCA FX by far. Anyhow, this is brilliant! As I've already told you, animation= perfection, sound= a whole lot of re-watching just to laugh again and again! You gotta start getting some credit for you sound editing too man, it's stellar!
Keep up the good work and looking forward to seeing you back at home base.

chluaid responds:

haha thanks man! My audio work is getting more complex with every project, but it's loads more fun on bite-sized projects like this :D

[Dance Mat - Stop-motion]

Pretty good...

I always feel like people are too damn generous with the star system here. I mean, you got all these 9's and 10's and it pretty much means don't do anything more, you got it all right! How can that be? Do people just feel bad about giving you a score lower than that? Sure, 4 is low, but it comes with justification.

First, yeah, this is NG and a pre-loader is a must, especially on a 8 mb file!! Otherwise you get people like me with 156 kb dsl line who have to pause the show and wait for some invisible loading, so points lost for that. I mean, this is a network of artist, go to the forum and ask how to add a pre-loader, especially if you already own FL.
Secondly, the whole thing was very well done! The scale was a bit 'off' and the unison of movements between the character and the moving objects wasn't timed properly. Obviously you know these things cause you made it, but here it does pay to listen and to appreciate those of us who say something more than, "oh, gosh, you have skills! Can't wait for another one!" Nope, not me, instead I would rather offer some perspective.

Lastly, I just would like to say welcome to NG if your subscription coincides with your upload. This is a great place to hone your skills and to appreciate a lot of wonderful artist! Staying tuned...

KERRUPT responds:

Thanks for the comments Banegame. I'm pleased to say I've just discovered how to attach a preloader so I'll be sure to include them in all my future uploads and, hopefully, I can work your suggestions into my future work. I should have some more up in the next few months.

Hope you're well.

[POP! an adventure]

What skills you have

Traditional animation at it's finest here. Loved everything about it, keep it up buddy.

turtleco responds:

I loved everything about your review ;)

[On The Palisade ep2]

AWESOMZE!!!!!

Great work! The laugh is a seller for sure. I recall seeing your other animation with these characters like a year ago or something and I totally forgot about them, thanks for the reminder and keep it up.

Jonimator responds:

It's out of 10 here haha. Your hurtin' me bud :P

[Bondish]

Randomness Confuses the mind

I get the stick guys, that hasn't been done yet. I also get the randomness of the compilation... the only thing I don't get is 'WHY'?!?!
Why have so many people work on 7600 frames of randomness? Isn't that like almost a short movie? I'd love to see what kind of sensible work you and the 29 other animators can construct while focusing on the fact that you're going to be tweening almost 8k frames!

Bond84 responds:

Well...it was 29 animators working towards a goal of random...What isn't to get?
This was actually pretty sensible, it gave everyone a freedom to do as they wished how they wished, some people such at Tentionmaru did a dragon with super glowy effects while a different user just hopped into a car. It left freedom for each person in a sensible and fun way.
There are also barely any tweens in comparison to the actual animation itself. There are *Maybe* 40-50
tweens in 7600 frames of animation...Half of those being for the credits.

[Spend It Wisely]

Bravo! Bravo!

I loved it! Great time, remindd me a lot of Ren and Stimpy. Had a certain Tarantino feel as well, with all the skipping around and cuts and all. Great job guys

TommyVF responds:

Tarantino? Woah, that's cool. Thanks.

[Lifeless]

Eventually I won't even bother

Why are there so many convoluted animations on NG? I seriously can't find more than a handful of animations that actually have a sensible story.

Bleak-Creep responds:

I'm sorry, it's meant to be more open ended so that you can make your own interpretation so that's part of it.